About the Animals: Horses

Horses1.png

It's common to think life forms evolve in neat, connected stages, progressing from one variation to the next in an orderly ladder that leads from the original ancestor to its present-day counterpart.

But sometimes the family tree turns out to be more of a bush, with branches that end relatively quickly, or develop in similar ways without being connected.

cormohipparion_600.jpg

Thanks to the work of generations of paleo sleuths and the fossils they’ve uncovered, we now know that horses have undergone this less-than-orderly style of evolution.

Horses began as leaf-eaters, with four toes on the forefoot and three on the hindfoot, and were as small as a Siamese cat. Now, they live as single-toed, long-legged grass-eaters that could easily outrun their ancestors.

Migration of the Horse

Click one of the buttons below the map to begin exploring how horses migrated over time
It was once thought horses were first introduced to the Americas by Spanish Explorers in the 1500s.
Horses came to North America as immigrants from the Old World 56 million years ago during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum. They show up in Europe and Asia at the same time and their place of origin is still a mystery. These early horses were very different than modern horses. They were much smaller and lived on a leafy diet.
The timing of the development of grasslands in central North America is not well understood, but it is clear that there was a major expansion of grasslands 6.5 MYA. Grasslands probably existed before this but were a patchwork or grasses and trees. Horses grew taller teeth in the middle Miocene, allowing them to consume grass, but the development of high-crowned teeth does not appear to correspond with the expansion of grassland. Scientists think the taller teeth may have developed in response to a drier climate, producing a greater amount of windblown grit, which would wear down a tooth faster.
Horses migrated to the Old World about fifteen million years ago and again ten million years ago, when sea level lowered, creating a land bridge across the Bering Strait. Horses remained abundant and diverse in North American until the expansion of C4 grasslands at the end of the Miocene, 6.5 MYA. A big drop in the number of species occurred with drying climate and expanding grasslands as only the species best adapted for open grasslands survived.
Horses remained abundant, but low in diversity, until ten thousand years ago when the climate warmed and the first human hunters arrived in North America. Horses abruptly went extinct at this time.
In the 1500s, horses once again traveled from one continent to another. But this time, they were sailing on ships instead of walking across land bridges, crossing the Atlantic Ocean to North America. The modern horse had come home.
56 MYA
20 MYA
15 MYA
10,000 YA
1500 YA

The Horse Evolutionary Tree

See how the ancestral horse lines evolved in sometimes-parallel lines of browsers and grazers who grew steadily taller and faster to become today’s horse.

Horse Evolution Tree

3D Models

Nebraska’s Pieces of the Puzzle

This state has supplied many pieces of the puzzle that help form the picture of changing climate and habitat, and its relationship to horse evolution.

Though some have been found in nearby Wyoming, so far Nebraska’s fossil record lacks specimens of the earliest horses. However, paleo sleuth Mike Voorhies discovered a deposit of sediment from the early Eocene in Knox County, Nebraska. This small deposit included "Hyracotherium," the earliest horse genus, though not the earliest species. The find is the only evidence in Nebraska of the lush early Eocene forests that grew from 66 to 45 MYA. Historical work was done here by paleo sleuth O.C. Marsh as well as by Mike Voorhies.

At Toadstool Park, a site with specimens from the late Eocene and Oligocene (about 37-28 MYA), primitive horses have been found -- only low-crowned browsers who ate leaves. There are no high-crowned grass eaters. All mammals that lived there are long extinct. It was warm and temperate in the late Eocene but drier and more open in the Oligocene. Historical work was done here by paleo sleuths by O.C. Marsh, Erwin Barbour and Mike Voorhies. Joseph Leidy also did work involving specimens from Toadstool Park. Secord, along with graduate student Grant Boardman, has published recent research on the mammal habitats at Toadstool.

At Norden Bridge, a Middle Miocene site from about 14 MYA, the climate at this time was warm and temperate with riparian (river-related) forest along stream channels. It had nearly frost-free winters (indicated by the presence of species like tortoises that could not tolerate long periods of freezing). It was home to both high-crowned horses (grazers) and low-crowned horses (browsers), indicating a mixed habitat. Historical work was done here by paleo sleuths Morris Skinner and Mike Voorhies.

Fossils from five kinds of horses were found at Ashfall Fossil Beds, where many communities of animals perished and were rapidly buried by a cloud of volcanic ash over the course of one to two months. This Middle Miocene site from 12 MYA was nearly frost-free at that time, with warm grasslands and riparian forests. Historical work was done here by paleo sleuth Mike Voorhies.

At Big Springs, a site from the Pleistocene (roughly 1.5 MYA), many large horse specimens (including zebras) have been found. The specimens suggest this was a warm interglacial interval of the Pleistocene (Ice Age). Historical work was done here by paleo sleuth Mike Voorhies. Recent research was published by Secord and his student, Zachary Kita, on the diets and habitats of horses, camels, elephants, and peccaries.